We earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn’t change our rankings or the price you pay.
Short answer: Mullvad if you want one flat price (€5/month including VAT), Proton VPN if you want a free tier, and something outside Nord Security if ownership is why you’re leaving. The right pick depends on which of those it is.
NordVPN shares Surfshark’s holding company, so switching to it won’t change the corporate group you pay.
We didn’t test these VPNs for this page. Every price and limit below comes from the providers’ own pricing and help pages, checked on 27 October 2026.
Why Are You Leaving Surfshark?
Find your reason in the left column, then jump to the section below that matches it.
| Your reason | Look at | Why it fits |
| The renewal price | Mullvad, PIA | Mullvad has a flat monthly rate. PIA’s annual plan renews at its first-year price |
| You want a free tier | Proton VPN Free, AdGuard VPN, Windscribe | No data cap on Proton Free. 3 GB on AdGuard VPN, 10GB on Windscribe |
| Privacy or jurisdiction | Proton VPN | Based in Geneva, says its apps are open source and audited |
| Simpler pricing or more devices | Mullvad, Windscribe, PIA | Mullvad has a flat price but a 5-device cap. Windscribe offers per-location pricing. Windscribe and PIA allow unlimited devices |
| The shared owner with NordVPN | Rule out NordVPN; check other owners | NordVPN shares Surfshark’s holding company. Other providers’ ownership wasn’t checked |
| A familiar name, owner doesn’t matter | NordVPN | 10 devices, 7-day web trial in 15 countries |
| You mostly used the ad blocker | ExpressVPN, AdGuard VPN, Proton VPN | Ad blocking on the cheapest tier or DNS filtering |
The Renewal Price Went Up
Surfshark’s current US Black Friday offer charges $67.23 upfront for Starter or One and $107.73 for One+, each covering 27 months. They then renew at $79, $99 and $119/year respectively. Sales tax may apply.
So compare what you’ll pay in year three, not month one.
Mullvad keeps it boring: €5 a month including VAT, whether you pay monthly or for a whole year. Its page lists that as about $5.58. There’s no free plan, and the pricing page says nothing about a money-back guarantee.
Private Internet Access bills its 1-year plan at $47.88 and renews it at the same $47.88/year. It also allows unlimited devices, like Surfshark. The captured page lists a 3-year plan with 3 extra months and renewal at $79 every 3 years. Confirm both the upfront total and renewal terms at checkout.
Plus is billed $83.76 up front for two years, and after that it’s $83.88 a year. Its annual cost roughly doubles at renewal. These USD prices were shown from Malta. Comparing renewal rates, Proton costs more than Surfshark Starter’s US rate but less than One or One+.
Check which Surfshark plan you’re on. In the current US Black Friday offer, Starter and One cost the same upfront on the 24-month term, but One renews $20/year higher. If you don’t use One’s extras, ask what switching to Starter would cost.
You Want a Free Tier
Surfshark offers new users a 7-day website trial on 12- and 24-month plans with a credit card, PayPal or Apple Pay. It covers 3 devices and charges for the chosen plan unless you cancel before the trial ends. Check the charge and renewal amount at signup; the post-trial price wasn’t verified.
The free plan doesn’t cap your data and doesn’t show ads. The catch is one device and a server in one of 10 randomly selected countries, so you can’t pick a location.
On the free tier you get 3 GB of data each month, usable on 2 devices. After that, speed drops, some servers lock and streaming stops working. It blocks ads and trackers with built-in DNS protection, which AdGuard keeps separate from its full ad blocker. Paid plans cover up to 10 devices and more than 75 locations. From Malta, the 1-year plan showed €50.85 including VAT upfront. Its listed renewal was €43.09 before VAT, but that wasn’t confirmed at checkout. Annual plans have a 30-day money-back guarantee; monthly plans can’t be refunded.
Windscribe Free gives you 10GB a month once you confirm an email. Build A Plan costs $1 per location per month with a $3 minimum, and each location adds 10GB. Pro costs $69 per 12 months.
Try Proton Free first. No data cap beats a bigger one.
Privacy or Jurisdiction
Surfshark’s pricing page lists Surfshark B.V. in Amsterdam, while its App Store seller is Surfshark Ltd. Several Surfshark legal entities exist, and we couldn’t confirm which one sells to buyers in each country.
If shared ownership is the issue, NordVPN doesn’t solve it. Switching keeps your money in the same corporate group.
Proton runs out of Geneva, and it publishes its apps as open source with third-party audits, by its own account. That’s Proton’s own claim, and we haven’t read the audit reports. Plus covers 10 devices and comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
A smaller privacy gripe has a simpler fix. Surfshark’s Google Play build now requires a Google sign-in, and Surfshark offers its official APK for people who don’t want that.
If the September 2026 incident is behind your decision, read Surfshark’s own report. It reports unauthorised access to a misconfigured internal test server and a separate proxy server. Exposed material included system binaries and internal configurations. Surfshark says “no user data and VPN services were affected”. Surfshark has promised an additional independent security audit.
Simpler Pricing or More Devices
More devices isn’t a reason to leave Surfshark. All three of its plans already allow unlimited simultaneous devices.
Most alternatives cap you. NordVPN, paid AdGuard VPN plans and Proton VPN Plus allow 10 devices. Mullvad allows 5, and ExpressVPN allows 10, 12 or 14 depending on the tier. PIA and Windscribe are the two on this page that also advertise unlimited devices.
Simpler pricing is a better reason. Mullvad has one price, and Windscribe lets you pay only for the locations you use. Both are easier to budget than a long promo term followed by a renewal price you have to look up.
You’d Rather Leave the Nord Group
Then NordVPN is off the list. Surfshark’s own About page says the two companies “merged under one holding company” in 2022 while “operating independently”.
They have different App Store sellers, help centres, pricing systems and refund policies. That shows separate storefronts, not separate ownership. Their 2022 promise of separate infrastructure wasn’t independently verified for this page.
We didn’t research who owns each of the other providers here. If ownership is what drives your choice, look that up before you buy.
You Want a Familiar Name and Don’t Mind the Shared Owner
NordVPN is an option if shared ownership doesn’t bother you and 10 simultaneous devices are enough. Up to 5 can use the same server, each using a different protocol.
Its 7-day website trial is for new users choosing a 1- or 2-year subscription with a card or PayPal in France, the US, Canada, Australia, the UK, Japan, the Netherlands, Germany, Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden, Spain, Italy or Poland. The help page leaves eligible plan tiers unclear. Android has its own shorter route: 3 days through Google Play for first-time users, though not in Bangladesh, India, South Korea or Sri Lanka. Cancel that trial through Google Play. NordVPN also says it emails you before a renewal price change.
We couldn’t verify NordVPN’s website prices, because its pricing page blocked our automated checks. The US App Store lists in-app subscriptions at $11.99 for a month and $83.99 for a year.
Those are store prices, not website prices. Check the website total and the renewal price before you pay.
You Mostly Used the Ad Blocker
If CleanWeb was the part you relied on, check what each alternative actually blocks. ExpressVPN’s Basic tier includes Lite Protection, which blocks ads, malicious sites and adult sites. Shown from Malta, Basic costs €69.72 upfront for the first 28 months and then €79.95/year. Sales tax is added at checkout where applicable.
Proton lists NetShield as a DNS-filtering ad blocker, but its plan and platform requirements weren’t verified here. AdGuard VPN uses DNS protection too. AdGuard says that’s not its full ad blocker, which is a separate product. Our guides to the VPNs with a built-in ad blocker and ad blocker vs VPN explain why the two jobs don’t fully overlap.
What Switching Costs You
The Refund Window
Surfshark offers a 30-day money-back guarantee on your first website purchase, requested through live chat. Previous refunds, renewals and purchases containing non-refundable services are excluded. If your purchase includes add-ons, check eligibility with support.
Bought through Apple? The refund goes through Apple, not Surfshark. Google Play is different. You can ask Google directly within 48 hours, and after that Surfshark support says it can help.
Cancelling Auto-Renewal
Cancelling and refunding are separate steps. Cancelling stops the next charge, keeps your access until the period ends and doesn’t refund the unused time. To cancel a website subscription:
- Log in to your Surfshark account on the website.
- Click your email address at the top right.
- Open Subscription, then Payments.
- Click “Cancel auto-renewal” (some help articles call it “Cancel renewal”) and confirm.
App Store and Google Play subscriptions have to be cancelled in the store. Changes made there don’t show up in your Surfshark account.
What You Lose
CleanWeb’s Chrome, Firefox and Edge extension includes ad and cookie pop-up blocking, plus data breach and malware alerts. If you choose a standalone ad blocker, check which of those features it covers, and our AdGuard vs Surfshark CleanWeb comparison shows how the two differ. If you want the details of what you’re giving up, see our Surfshark CleanWeb page.
Alternative ID is the easy one to forget. It gives you a made-up persona and a masked email that forwards to your real inbox. We couldn’t confirm what happens to that forwarding after you cancel, so move any accounts that use the masked address to an email you control first.
On One+, you also lose Incogni, which sends data-removal requests to company databases and people-search sites. It only works for US, UK, EU, Swiss and Canadian residents, so outside those places you weren’t getting it anyway.
And check how the new provider handles refunds before you pay anything. AdGuard VPN won’t refund monthly plans, NordVPN’s guarantee covers only your first subscription, and Mullvad’s pricing page doesn’t promise a refund at all.
Reasons to Stay With Surfshark
Some reasons to leave don’t hold up.
Unlimited devices on every plan is the big one, and only PIA and Windscribe match it on this list. Starter also bundles the VPN, Alternative ID and an ad blocker. If you use those extras, count what replacing them would cost.
Surfshark claims more than 4,500 servers in 100 countries and an audited no-logs policy, but its pricing page doesn’t name the auditor, so treat the audit as Surfshark’s own claim until you’ve seen the report.
If you’re leaving One or One+ over renewal cost, ask Surfshark what moving to Starter would cost. Its listed US renewal is $79/year, but downgrade terms weren’t verified. Our link opens the current offer.